The late Roddy McDowall, a nice fellow who had a multitude
of pals and took his friendships very seriously, once
told me that when he first met a person, whenever the
conversation would get around to movies, he'd always
ask, "Do you like Irene Dunne?" If the answer was "no",
said Roddy, he knew then and there that he and that
person female or male, old or young, celebrity or mailman
could never be friends. He was kidding, but not
entirely. He said quite earnestly,, "If a someone doesn't
like Irene Dunne, what's wrong with them?" Fair question.
Today, the only thing wrong with such a query is that too
many people don't know the work of this amazingly
versatile lady, something we're hopefully going to help
change this month with a 28-film smorgasbord of Irene
Dunne films, which range from sophisticated comedies
to screwball farces, from romantic dramas to melodic musicals, from a western epic to a melodramatic tale in which
Myrna Loy (!) tries to kill off Irene and a group of her sorority sisters. (Check out Irene being good and Myrna being
bad in Thirteen Women on Dec. 6.)
Throughout this month on TCM, you can also get a look at all five of the Irene Dunne
performances which brought her Academy Award® nominations: Cimarron, Theodora Goes Wild, The Awful Truth, Love
Affair and I Remember Mama. Well deserved they were, too; the only stunner is that she never went on to win an
Oscar®, not even an honorary A.A. for her extraordinary body of work. During Hollywood's golden age, the delightful
Dunne was as big a star as any in the film business. She was also one of the few in that fabled era of iron-clad studio
contracts who had the courage and confidence to spend most of her career as a freelance actress. Except for six early
years as a contractee at RKO, she was never tied to a single studio. That was considered equal to career suicide in the
mid-1930s and 1940s when the major film companies always saved their best scripts for their own "family" members;
outsiders didn't have much of a chance. Because of her talent and popularity, however, Irene still managed to get the
pick of the litter.
20th Century-Fox stars Gene Tierney and Maureen O'Hara both campaigned vigorously to win the
lead in Fox's 1946 biggie Anna and the King of Siam but it was given instead to the free-wheeling Ms. Dunne. Bette
Davis, during the era she reigned supreme at Warner Bros., desperately wanted to play "Mama" in Warners movie
version of the famous Broadway success Life with Father and even did a screen test for it (and, for the record, so did
Claudette Colbert, Rosalind Russell, even Mary Pickford who came out of a 14-year retirement to test) but it was Irene
who nabbed the role. It would require several books to even list the great roles first offered to Dunne but which, for
various reasons, she declined, among them Now, Voyager, Gaslight, Mr. Skeffington, all the way to The Lady in
Ermine.
Something which amazes me about this lady: she made such an indelible presence
it films, it's difficult to fathom she made movies for only 22 years (1930-52), by contrast,
today's Robert DeNiro and Harrison Ford, for two examples, have each been making
films for over 40 years,with no signs whatsoever of slowing down. Think of the great work
we missed because Ms. Dunne decided to exit when she did. But, as her fan Mr. McDowall
often expressed it, we're extremely grateful there was an Irene Dunne. Don't be surprised
if her presence on TCM this month turns out to be the Christmas present you enjoy most.
by Robert Osborne
Robert Osborne on Irene Dunne
by Robert Osborne | November 26, 2007
SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTERS
CONNECT WITH TCM