"Under different intentions, it might have made a decent grade-C Roger Corman bike movie-- though Corman has generally used more interesting directors than Guercio. It is in fact a murder mystery, in which a higher-principled Arizona motorcycle cop discovers the death of an old recluse and, against all odds, finds out who killed the man and why. Upon this slender plot is grafted lots of excess cinema, and a really unfair share of meaning."
Roger Greenspan, The New York Times

"A forgotten gout amid the spume of the American new wave, James William Guercio's 1973 Midwestern policier is a grim, ambivalent rejoinder to the generational agitprop of Easy Rider...it's a living flashback, all desert dust, arty compositions, working-class despair, and a potent sense of outlaw critical mass. The ending, echoing and overshadowing Rider's, is a masterfully appalling moment in an era chockablock with convulsions." Michael Atkinson, The Village Voice

"Yet, warts and all, there are ways in which Electra Glide in Blue might be considered the real picture of the year: with its careful attempt to touch all bases in appealing to the prejudices of, and the worst in, practically everybody, probably as good a movie as any to serve as a record for posterity of the spectrum of bad feeling which characterized this fifth year of the Nixon Era..."
William S. Pechter, Commentary

"Alternately genial and portentous, this nervy 1973 Panavision inversion of the Easy Rider formula stars Robert Blake as an Arizona motorcycle cop grappling with existential issues. James William Guercio's direction rips off virtually every icon in the American cinematic shrine, from the monumental vistas of John Ford westerns to the leather-and-chrome fetishism of the Corman biker epics, and chaotically combines wide-screen close-ups in shallow focus, sweeping panoramas, slapstick, bathos, pathos, and two performances of occasional subtlety from Blake and Billy Green Bush. The period politics, which equate the highway patrol with fascism, are dumb and messy."
Don Druker, Chicago Reader

"Striking one-off by a former record producer. A weirdly funny black comedy about an undersized cop, barely five feet tall...the film has an extraordinary texture, peeling away layer after layer to reveal dark depths of loneliness and despair as this cop Candide learns that he isn't living in the best of all possible worlds. And Conrad Hall's photography, especially of the Monument Valley landscapes is a joy."
Tom Milne, TimeOut Film Guide

"Something of a cop version of Easy Rider, Electra Glide in Blue (released in 1973) has moments of strained pretentiousness but is nevertheless, extremely effective in showing the fruitless attempts of one truly good cop. Blake gives a poignant, layered performance as the motorcycle cop wishing to rise the ranks to detective. And it's distinctly Blake-ian in the actor's ability to be simultaneously bizarre and touching. There is just something so off about him. The notion that a cop is this by the book makes him a curious outsider-more of a rebel."
Kim Morgan, Sunset Gun

"Filmed in 1973, Electra Glide in Blue was a contemporary slice of the turmoil that existed during that time...The movie holds up today for the simple reason that its director Guercio and screenwriters Robert Boris and Rupert Hitzig present the opposing forces on display in an unbiased manner. The cops and the counterculture are both shown warts and all...the movie holds up today without feeling dated."
Rusty White, Entertainment Insiders

"Electra Glide purports to be a sort of Easy Rider for the motorcycle-cop set as Wintergreen sets out to find out what he's really made of and what he really wants out of life, but often the movie nearly collapses under the weight of its own good intentions (and pretensions). It combines a fairly standard-issue mystery plot with action scenes, moral questions, and arthouse sensibilities in an overbaked mixture that often works, but not always. It's still worth seeing for Blake's sake; he's always been an actor who's not afraid to take on offbeat roles."
Jerry Renshaw, Austin City Chronicle

"Electra Glide in Blue is an unusual film, a good example of the 70s penchant for mixing (or if you prefer, undermining) established genres...Politically this is a hard film to call, being neither pro-cop nor pro-hippie, and stylistically it's a mixture of traditional classicism and what was then cutting-edge technique. But as a fascinating one-off of its period, Electra Glide in Blue is well worth seeing.
Gary Couzens, DVD Times

"The... film is not for all tastes but it is a joy for the adventurous viewer."
Don Guarisco, AllMovie.com

"At times, Electra Glide in Blue feels like it is about to jump the rails, cartwheeling into the anything-goes realm of exploitation. Yet every time, Blake's intense, sincere performance pulls the film back on track and holds our interest. He is an interesting actor with real screen presence..."
Judge Steve Evans, DVDVerdict.com

"Made at a time when America hadn't just lost its way but had also misplaced its A-Z, Electra Glide is the product of a disciplined filmmaker who understands both actors and the power of the empty frame. How unfortunate that (James William Guercio) should have decided that making records with Chicago was more exciting than haggling with producers."
Richard Luck, Channel14.com

"Boasting cinematographic bravado by director of photography Conrad Hall, the film is full of terrific compositions. Hall captures the desolate Arizona highways and the desperate conditions of communal living, along with nicely played-out action sequences with stylized camera-play. Hall's skilled photography is one of the main aspects of the film that elevates it above the status of just a plan action/murder-mystery...Electra Glide in Blue is an overlooked film that reveals its ambiguous morality in subtle ways similar to other films of the decade...the film deserves to be on the map with the other efforts of quintessential '70s cinema."
Bill Blick, SensesofCinema.com

"Electra Glide in Blue was made during Blake's hey-day in the 70s and he's actually pretty darn good in this one, playing a by-the-book cop with dreams of carrying a detective's badge, investigating the cases no one else sees (or wants to see). Factor in some pretty spectacular cinematography (still 70s cinematography, but gorgeous nonetheless) and an intriguing tale and you have a pretty entertaining flick that can still hold the interest of this viewing audience, despite not being born when this gem graces the big screen."
CalgaryMovies.com

"(Electra Glide in Blue) could never be construed as written by the winners, because it maps out the dynamics of corruption too complexly and refuses to say the little man is good because he's doomed. The truth is perhaps more painful, but it's also a great deal less certain."
Travis Mackenzie Hoover, Film Freak Central

"One of the great-unsung films of the 1970s, Electra Glide in Blue...stands as a fine example that epitomizes a glorious, but all too brief time of filmmaking after the limitations of the studio system and the restrictions of the Hays Codes collapsed, and before political correctness and the 'blockbuster' mentality overtook modern-day Hollywood, and being real was all a filmmaker had to worry about."
Chuck O'Leary, FulvueDrive-in.com

"(Electra Glide in Blue) arrived at a tumultuous time when the old divisions between cowboy and Indian, black hat and white hat, and villain and hero were becoming hopelessly blurred. In keeping with the zeitgeist, it's a thriller where solving the central crime seems somewhat irrelevant: Only thinly disguised as a cop movie, Electra is a profound and ultimately tragic meditation on identity, belonging, and the fickleness of the American Dream. It circles around genres only to dismantle and reassemble them in more truthful ways."
Nathan Rabin, The Onion A.V. Club

"I truly love Conrad Hall's work on Electra Glide in Blue, which makes use of a lot of very long lenses and looks completely unique.
Josh Becker, director Sea of Love (1989)

Compiled by Richard Harland Smith