First off, let's erase a wild misconception
about our Star of the Month for
November, the elegant Norma Shearer.
For many years Norma was touted as
the "First Lady of MGM," reigning as
the Queen of that legendary studio for
the first 18 years of it's existence (1924-40).
She was indeed Queen Norma, but not
for the reason her most vocal rival Joan
Crawford always gave. According to
Joan, Norma got all the best parts
"because she was sleeping with the
boss." To give Joan her due, that
was partially true: Norma indeed
bedded down with the boss, MGM's
head of production Irving Thalberg,
but did so legitimately--she was Mrs.
Irving Thalberg.
However, if her films
hadn't consistently made big profits
and pulled big lines at movie box-offices
around the country no one, not
even the brilliant Thalberg, would
have been allowed by studio investors
and shareholders to continue giving
her the starring roles in so many of the
studios most important and costly
projects; in Norma's case, those films
included the movie versions of such
award-winning plays as Private Lives,
Strange Interlude, Smilin' Through, The Barretts
of Wimpole Street, Romeo and Juliet,
Idiot's Delight and The Women.
Would a
studio head, even in Hollywood's
golden days, be able to push someone
off on the public solely based on a
personal interest? No way. Examples:
in the 1930s, 20th Century-Fox head
honcho Darryl F. Zanuck spent a great
deal of moola attempting to interest
moviegoers in paying to see French
bon-bon Simone Simon; the public's
response was nil and she quickly disappeared
from the Fox payroll. Also in
the '30s, independent producer Samuel
Goldwyn spent millions trying to
turn Russian-born Anna Sten into a
popular star in America. The public so
consistently cold-shouldered her it
was soon "do svidaniya, Anna."* In the
1940s, the head of Republic Pictures,
Herbert Yates, tried to turn his wife,
ex-Ice Capade skater Vera Hruba
Ralston, into a movie star--an uphill
battle for Yates from the get-go. Even
casting her opposite such top box-office
names as John Wayne and Fred
MacMurray didn't help. It resulted in
Yates himself being ousted from the
studio he had created, all because
those films he insisted must star wife
Vera consistently tanked.
Norma
Shearer's situation was quite the opposite.
Her films, except for her final
two, brought in big profits for MGM,
a primary reason the MGM bosses
treated her as they did after Thalberg's
death in 1937, first going ahead with a
Shearer project spearheaded by Thalberg,
1938's Marie Antoinette, the most
expensive film MGM had made up to
that time. Soon after, Norma was the
first actress offered the leads in such
important MGM projects as Pride and
Prejudice and Mrs. Miniver, both of which
she chose to not do. But it's not just
her grosses but her work that is the
real proof of why she was such an immensely
important star, and every
Tuesday this month on TCM you can
see 22 grand examples of that work.
Few have been more radiant or more
loved by a motion picture camera than
she. And if you're not already a Norma
Shearer devotee, I'll wager you will be
long before the month is over.
*"bye, bye, Anna."
by Robert Osborne
Robert Osborne on Norma Shearer
by Robert Osborne | October 23, 2015
SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTERS
CONNECT WITH TCM