Shot in the actual apartments and streets of a recently liberated Rome, Open City, like other neorealist films, was distinguished by an almost documentarian quality, an immediacy and sense of truth that made the film a box-office success in Italy, Europe and the United States. Rossellini's innovative film style was so new and naturalistic that some believed the events were filmed as they actually happened.
Open City centers on the efforts of the Nazi occupiers to capture a partisan leader, Giorgio Manfredi (Marcello Pagliero), who is assisted by a noble local priest, Don Pietro Pellegrini (Aldo Fabrizi). The efforts of the Resistance are set against the ordinary, daily struggles of the Italian people who storm a bakery to give bread to their starving children, or struggle with the moral uncertainties of wartime. Pina is one of those people, engaged to be married to the kind Francesco (Francesco Grandjacquet), a friend of Resistance fighter Manfredi. Pina is already pregnant with Francesco's child, and thus embodies some of the moral ambiguities of wartime as characters struggle to live a decent life despite enormous incentives to do otherwise. One of the characters who succumbs to the temptations offered during wartime is Manfredi's mistress Marina (Maria Michi), a beautiful but essentially shallow girl who ends up being led by Nazi agent Ingrid (Giovanna Galletti) to betray Manfredi.
Though noted for its exceptionally strong performances, especially by Magnani and Fabrizi, Open City has also been criticized for its blend of tragedy and comedy as well as for its melodramatic elements which some have considered out of character with the true essence of neorealism as later practiced by Luchino Visconti and Vittorio De Sica. Rossellini's use of emotionally manipulative dramatic effects was most obvious in his opposition of noble, morally upright Italians against often cartoonish Nazi villains, including the absurdly effete Major Bergmann (Harry Feist), who directs the torture of Resistance leaders while casually smoking a cigarette, and an outrageous, glamorous lesbian who uses drugs and fur coats to compel Marina to betray Manfredi.
Though the film received positive notice in a 1946 Variety review, the article did speculate, in an outlandish aside, about some of the potentially objectionable material for American audiences, including a premaritally pregnant Pina, references to cocaine, and the aforementioned "lesbo German spy." Though nothing is explicitly shown, Rossellini also so effectively evokes the horrors of Manfredi's torture by the Nazis, that the scene becomes one of the most sickening, disturbing moments in film history.
Neorealist films like Open City were important not only as a means of commemorating Italian struggle and sacrifice during the war -- they served an important function in resuscitating an Italian film industry suddenly threatened with the new dominion of Hollywood and other national cinemas in the postwar era.
It was not only Rossellini's real locations and the grainy texture of his film that imparted realism to the project. Many of the events depicted in the film, from priest Don Pietro's execution by firing squad to pregnant Pina being gunned down by a Nazi soldier, were based on actual events various collaborators on the project witnessed or heard about during wartime. The terror of wartime was still so fresh on Italian minds, it invested their work on Open City with a raw, often painful intensity, as in the scene where Pina is murdered in front of her fiance and small son. As Magnani recalled, extras on the scene "actually turned white telling each other how much they resented the Nazis! This made me feel the anxiety I showed on the screen."
Producer/Director: Roberto Rossellini
Screenplay: Sergio Amidei, Federico Fellini and Roberto Rossellini (based on a story by Amidei and Alberto Consiglio)
Cinematography: Ubaldo Arata
Production Design: Rosario Megna
Music: Renzo Rossellini
Principal Cast: Anna Magnani (Pina), Aldo Fabrizi (Don Pietro Pellegrini), Marcello Pagliero (Giorgio Manfredi), Maria Michi (Marina), Harry Feist (Maj. Bergmann), Francesco Grandjacquet (Francesco), Giovanna Galletti (Ingrid).
by Felicia Feaster