- Acting of Lead Performers
- Acting of Supporting Cast
- Music Score
- Title Sequence
- Historical Importance
- Would You Recommend?
0 Member Ratings
NO REVIEWS AVAILABLE
The title has not been reviewed. Be the first to write a review by clicking here to start.
Horn and the Man
- Donald Weber
As several others have said, they've watched this a number of times and I have also. It has to be near the top of my ten favorite movies of all time. I'm in a quandary over which picture has the best jazz - Young Man With A Horn or Pete Kelly's Blues. More than the miserable marriage to Amy bringing him to his self-destruction, I think it was the death of his adoptivish father, Art Hazard (Juano Hernandez) that pushed him to the bottom. I somewhat agree that the happy ending might have been the wrong way to go, but when you love the character the redemption is welcome. It's too bad that that couldn't have been the real story for Bix. And what about Smoke? Hoagy was the perfect partner for Rick.
Good, but the ending??
AFter hearing the comments on TCM, i agree, the ending seems rushed and too happy. I usually like happy endings, but in keeping with the rest of the movie, and the story, I wish it was something more real. It wouldnt have to be a total tragedy, but something different than what was in that script. The commentators said the actors did not want the film to end as it did, but Jack Warner wanted an upbeat finale.Doris Day and Kirk Douglas are excellent, and Doris sounds very bluesy, which i havent always heard in her voice....Bacall has an interesting part as a very bright, but confused rich girl.Hoagy Carmichael plays wonderfully and does a super job. No one has mentioned the great Juano Hernandez who shines in every movie he is in.
Reasons Why Movies Matter
- George Findley
I can think of three reasons for watching movies: 1) because they teach you something you didn't know, 2) because they excite/entertain you with action/excitement/thrills and 3) because the movie reminds you of values that touch your emotions. This movie is the third type.
Great music, great Day, but so so film
- Oliver Cutshaw
This is one of those uneasy films for me to view. It has excellent music, supplied by Harry James, wonderful vocals by Doris Day, and even a few hints of serious themes (race, sexuality, American musical history). But somehow it just does not work.Some reviewers blame the lack of chemistry between Doris Day and Kirk Douglas. Its true they don't really mix. But honestly there is plenty of fine acting... Hoagy and Lauren almost steal the picture.It think the real problem is the tagged-on happy ending and the somewhat melodramatic script that just doesn't have time to let the characters breathe and develop. However, the sound track is excellent. So take a look and a listen sometime.
Young Man With A Horn
- Bruce Reber
I've seen "Young Man With A Horn" several times, and I recorded it on VHS when it aired on TCM in December 2010. It's a powerful story of Rick Martin, a lonely kid who buys a second hand trumpet. When he hears a jazz band playing in a club he immediately develops a deep love for the music, and when he grows up he's a talented musician focused on one thing only-playing as a jazz trumpeter in a big band. He gets a job with a band and meets its singer Jo Jordan, who introduces him to Amy North, a shallow heiress. A complicated love triangle soon develops-Rick is torn between Jo, Amy and his music. After an ill-fated marriage to Amy Rick starts drinking and suffers a mental collapse. With the help of Jo he learns about his inner self and makes a comeback. All three of the major stars give fine performances-Kirk Douglas as Rick, Doris Day as Jo and Lauren Bacall as Amy. Hoagy Carmichael is also good as Rick's pianist friend Smoke.
Great film with Doris Day and Kirk Douglas
I love these old black and white films of the 40s and 50s. This is a great story about a jazz artist, his life and the women he's involved with. Doris Day is simply amazing an amazing actress, she keeps suprizing me in her dramatic roles, she just shines in all genres, doesn't she? Kirk Douglas does a great job and is very believable as the "Young Man with a Horn".
A Wonderful Discovery
- David Meuel
I have been watching classic films for 50 years, and I am amazed that -- from time to time -- I keep discovering overlooked and vastly underrated gems. My latest is Michael Curtiz' YOUNG MAN WITH A HORN from 1950. What especially struck me is how good it is in so many ways: the music, the acting, the direction, and the cinematography. The sound track, I am told, is a favorite among jazz enthusiasts and deservedly so. Harry James' trumpet playing is so bold and poetic at the same time. And the haunting "Melancholy Rhapsody," which is played throughout, has a powerful impact. The acting is wonderful. Kirk Douglas has never been more authentically intense, and Doris Day is just perfect as a genuinely good-hearted woman who wants love and settles for friendship. The look of the film is exhilarating too. I love how Curtiz frames so many of this shots to underscore the drama, and I love the beautiful black and white cinematography. Visually it is as arresting as many of the much better known film noirs of the period. So, if you love jazz, Michael Curtiz films, or early Kirk Douglas, this film is a must-see!
Young Man With A Horn
- Philip Ruisi
I have seen that movie a least a hundred times, And I will never get tired of seeing it. Kirk Douglas and Doris Day are the greatest Actors I have ever seen. I love that movie because I am a Trumpet player. Its too bad that they do not make movies like that anymore.
Young Man With a Horn
- Ray Marlitz
Man with Trumpet tries to Make it
Great Movie with a great cast!
- william warning
I have seen this movie a number of times and it never gets old. Kirk Douglas in his prime, Doris Day playing a real person is fresh as a diasy and has some super big band scenes singing some real classics.Hoagy Carmichal is perfect as the salty old piana player with a heart of gold. The sets and directiom by Michal Curtiz are perfect. And there is even Lauren Becall looking very young and very Laureen Becallish. This movie has every old Warner bros. cliche in the book and its played, and directed perfectly. Don't miss this one or any film directed by Michal Curtiz.