- Acting of Lead Performers
- Acting of Supporting Cast
- Music Score
- Title Sequence
- Historical Importance
- Would You Recommend?
0 Member Ratings
NO REVIEWS AVAILABLE
The title has not been reviewed. Be the first to write a review by clicking here to start.
Janet Leigh Shines !
- DON RILEY
No, Janet Leigh may not be at the pinnacle of Female film stars. But, she is so very good. She shines brightly here. Billy Bob Thornton states ....." ...you feel sorry for Jimmy Stewart."...........His statement is a general one but I do believe he's saying something very insightful. Because we actually DO feel sorry for Jimmy Stewart in many of his roles. Basically because he comes across many times as being inadequate. Being a flawed character, a character who's humanness leads more than his ego. That again happens in this film, a flawed angry defeated, desperate man. A man who faces so many adversities and yet in a very humbling way finds a greater good. 3 1/2 stars. Also, the script and direction is able to place Robert Ryan and Ralph Meeker together as antagonists and have it work.
Stewart Is Excellent
When James Stewart made westerns he did something most other actors could never do. He played the part of vulnerable and flawed individuals. He plays this role just this way in The Naked Spur. Stewart's western characters are three dimensional and believable. He's a tormented guy in this film but when contrasted with the almost psychopathic character played by Robert Ryan, Stewart's character evokes empathy and support. There is a good cast and the scenery is incurably beautiful in this film. In fact, the film just wouldn't work had it been filmed in the desert Southwest, for example. The rugged Rockies provide a challenge for Stewart's character and for Ralph Meeker's character as well. You want them both to make it, to find the fairness they seek. I love Jimmy Stewart n any western because he's the real deal. He is never a blow hard, shoot 'em first, win every time cowboy. He is human and he struggles with the issues and fears we all have as he tries to find his way in life.
- Tom Byrne
The speaking parts, and every other audio aspect of this entire movie are rerecorded. It ruins an otherwise great movie. You're totally aware that these are actors, trying to sync their voices, in a recording studio, with their performances on film. The sounds of the voices, rapids, gunfire, everything, is overdubbed. Makes it impossible to lose oneself in the movie. This is never commented upon, but to me, it's just glaring.
- Susanne Cavendish
I found the four supporting actors more interesting than Jimmy Stewart. This was a movie about four men, each looking for a way to change their lives, their luck or their predicament. Lina Patch [Leigh] was just looking for a home, someone to be with. Jesse Tate [Millard] was a miner a man in search of the elusive vein of gold which others always seemed to tell him about. Jimmy Stewart, a rancher who returned from the war to find his ranch had been sold by the woman he trusted to look after it, now was in search of the bounty on the head of Ben [Ryan] who was wanted for murdering a law officer. In the end each escaped their plight by dying, being killed or letting go of that which imprisoned them, kept them from seeing all else, but that state of being and the way out of it, they believed was the only way to escape. It was wonderfully done, with a bit too much to believe. in an Indian fight which was precipitated by the other companion in search of his freedom, Roy [Meeker]. The environment in which the movie was shot was scenic and lent itself to the ways and means each needed to find their ways out of the maze of self-destruction, three by way of death. As a western, as any kind of movie, I liked it.
Robert Ryan, preying psychopath
- Will Fox
Great ensemble cast staring Jimmy Stewart, cast against type, as America's favorite character actor and a comic, stretching beyond his brand, as "Harvey," a big bunny's Best Friend Forever, buying drinks for everyone. Now, Post-World-War-2 veteran Stewart plays a Post Traumatic Stress Civil War victim, a self centered, desperate, money-grubbing bounty hunter. He is a pilgrim on a long journey toward redemption. Enroute he meets grizzly Millard Mitchell, an old prospector, that is naively manipulated via greed for fool's gold. They soon meet a cavalier, a cavalry cad, played by Ralph Meeker, recently dishonorably discharged from the US Army and most recently, pursued by vengeful Indians. These character actors chase a wanted outlaw. His $5000 bounty is worth a fortune in 1868 dollars. Who better to play the murderous villain than Robert Ryan, the infamous, psychopathic murderer in "Crossfire" (1947) and a particularly nasty, Sundance Kid in "The Return of the Bad Men" (1948). In the "Naked Spur" (1953), after being captured, rascally Robert Ryan rebounds repeatedly, masterfully manipulating modest minds, more money focused. His clever, divide-and-conquer tactics work, setting a great precedent for his mastermind villainy in "Bad Day at Black Rock" (1955) as Reno Smith, the racist bully, dastardly deceiver, deadly destroyer that finally goes to prison with his gang of criminals. The "Naked Spur" finale has Jimmy Stewart converted by the Tinkerbell-esque, Janet Leigh, an orphan offering love forever, if he will give up the body of the bounty. Her love redeems.
The Naked Spur
- Dashiell B.
Another tough, brillantly-written Western directed by Mann & starring Stewart. Stewart is excellent as a bounty hunter on the verge of hysteria who sets to capture Ryan's killer, who create's tension among the films group. Beautifully shot in the Rocky Mountains, the film is an excellent study of greed & exploration of the various characters. Brutal and entertaining, a Western well worth watching. I give it a 4.5/5.
The Naked Spur (1953)
- Jay Higgins
Exceptional western. Jimmy Stewart is one of those actors whose mere presence in a film makes it worth watching. He defines the word professional. Well directed, good cinematography.
A Hidden Gem
Jimmy Stewart seems a tad awkward in his western cowboy roles, but we overlook this because we know he is giving his all to his role, and we love every minute. This film is equivalent to a western film noir- dark, mysterious, distant, suspenseful- the juxt of good and evil. And like a great film noir, one can drift off into the cinematic beauty of the film, while the story begins to arise in the eastern sky, shining through the aspens, and a long day later, setting far beyond our view. So few films allow us to immerse ourselves in them, giving us life as we give them.
Depth, comlexity and humanity
James Stewart and Anthony Mann were a rare combination of actor and director. Their western films rival the Stewart/Hitchcock films for psychological depth and complex characters. "The Naked Spur" shows that James Stewart can somehow play dark, even unsympathetic characters yet, still give them a humanity that makes the character appealing. His acting talents were a rare gift and this picture was one of the finest showcases of his emotional range. And Mann, directs all the performers beautifully. Highly recommended. One of our finest westerns.
The series of westerns directed by Anthony Mann and starring James Stewart are rated among the best films of the genre. Many of these movies are available on DVD: "Bend of the River", "Winchester '73", "The Far Country", "The Man From Laramie", etc. "The Naked Spur" is one of the films in the series and, in my estimation, is the best of the bunch. It is very frustrating and I hope that the entities responsible will see fit to fill this major gap in the DVD market.