Home Video Reviews
Though the screenplay by Charles Marquis Warren (working from an original story by Frank Gruber) plays fast and loose with historical fact, Pony Express remains a fairly compelling piece of American frontier storytelling, with Heston's sagebrush savant and Tucker's more citified (and clean-shaven - the real Hickock grew his trademark handlebar moustache to hide a protuberant upper lip that got him branded "Duck Bill" Hickock) gunfighter taking a stand against sibling isolationists Rhonda Fleming and Michael Moore (Stalag 17), who want to foil the Pony Express and keep California from siding with the anti-slavery Union. Although directed by Jerry Hopper with a decided lack of urgency, Pony Express retains its currency half a century later in depicting a fractious nation torn between the efforts of forward-thinking progressives (including Jan Sterling as a prairie tomboy) and old school obstructionists (personified by dastardly Henry Brandon as a beetle-browed secondary villain and the more Albert Dekker-like Stuart Randall, whose outward show of gentility masks a blackly rapacious soul). Heston (fresh from King Vidor's Ruby Gentry) and Tucker share an easy rapport but the Cody-Hickock partnership bears surprisingly meager fruit given the titanic dimensions of their historical footprints.
Brought to DVD from the Paramount vaults by Olive Films, Pony Express looks very nice in its digital debut. The film's slightly-wider-than-standard aspect ratio (1.37:1) has been preserved on this Region 1 DVD and the transfer is both clean and pleasingly chromatic, with warm flesh tones and a satisfyingly variegated desert palate throughout. The monaural soundtrack is not very dynamic but acceptable and clear. There are no extras and Olive's keepcase art includes a bit of a spoiler for the film's disarmingly tragic conclusion.
For more information about Pony Express, visit Olive Films. To order Pony Express, go to TCM Shopping.
by Richard Harland Smith